Latest Articles >

I have bad references. What do I do?

4 May 2016 | by Anne B-Godbout |

You did it! You updated your CV and landed your dream job. Just one problem: your bad references are holding you back. What should you do? Here are a few tips that will get you hired despite that drawback.

“It’s rare to find a candidate who can’t provide at least two good references,” says Mélanie Roy, recruiter. “In my 13 years of experience, I’ve only seen one person who believed he had provided favorable references, when they were all negative.” Since references are often required to land a job, it’s preferable to leave a company on good terms.”

Were you fired from a company a few years ago, but still want to use it as a reference? “Call them up and ask them,” advises Suzanne Lucas, human resources manager. “If it was a few years ago, and you didn’t do anything serious, chances are, the situation may have improved.” “Phone your former boss directly,” she continues, “explain that you’re looking for a new job, and ask what kind of reference he’d be willing to give you.”

Mélanie Roy stresses that interviewers weigh far more than references: “Most people can provide at least two good references, but they often fail to realize that their activity sector is small, and that it’s important to maintain a good reputation, because everything comes out in the end. The professionalism and ethics you display to providers, clients and your colleagues will influence people’s perceptions about you.”

Vindictive former bosses
Even though they have provided a positive written reference, former bosses may say something else entirely on the phone. In the US, there are now companies that provide a reference checking service for people who want to know what former employers are saying about them. “If a former employer says something like: I’d never hire him, he’s stupid and incompetent, it’s a form of slander and you can sue,” says Jeff Shane, founder of Allison and Taylor, a reference checking company.

This service doesn’t appear to be available yet in Canada, but this kind of thing, while rare, has been known to happen. Jeff Shane advises calling a vindictive former boss or sending him a letter, since your reputation is at stake.

In general, Mélanie Roy advises transparency. “If you can’t provide relevant references, it’s always preferable to be honest with the recruiter, explain that you learned a lesson and were able to make the most of a work experience that ended badly.”

Something good comes from every misfortune: explain that you’ve developed new skills, demonstrate a sincere desire to improve yourself, be the very best you can, and ideally, provide concrete examples to back up your assertions. Demonstrating honesty, humility and respect will win you points with your future employer.

Daniel Matera
The reality is the majority of fortune 500 and larger companies have policies against managers providing references for liability reasons. They advise employees they need to contact H/R for employment reference purposes. The ironic thing is, these same companies request references from direct managers for the people they hire. The vast majority of companies no longer use recruitment firms for non senior roles. They use entry level h/r administrators to screen resumes on online applicant tracking systems. This introduces a whole other set of challenges because of how candidates are screened. These entry level h/r admin's have very limited work/ life experience and thus are unable to successfuly interpret an individual's qualifications as it relates to the role being applied for. Many hiring managers such as myself are quite often challenged with h/r's poor selection of candidates. Consequently I always need to review all the submitted CV's myself in order to ascertain who's most qualified for the role I am hiring for.
In conclusion, my sentiments toward the overall H/R process is they (H/R) are more of an impediment than an enabler. And unfortunately many policies as it relates to H/R and employee references are a double standard.
28/04/2017 8:36:09 AM
ruven samaraweera
Hi I m sunita I m findout the job in I.T my study diploma in computing level 7 my collage name ntec collage in auckland plz I can apply ur visit site plz help me
28/02/2017 1:48:31 PM
sunita kumari
Hi I m sunita I m findout the job in I.T my study diploma in computing level 7 my collage name ntec collage in auckland plz I can apply ur visit site plz help me
26/01/2017 1:09:10 AM
Leave comment

 Security code